top of page

The Craft Corner: Bookish Pumpkin Painting

Writer: Amber Hathaway
Amber Hathaway
Oct 24
3 min read
Hallowed Deadly Seeds pumpkin painted for Halloween 2026.
Hallowed Deadly Seeds pumpkin painted for Halloween 2026.

What better way to celebrate spooky season than with some pumpkin decorating? While pumpkin carving may be more popular, pumpkin painting is a great alternative if you'd like your pumpkin to last for a long time. If you're considering this craft as part of a book club, gourds or small pumpkins are a cost-effective option that can be more easily painted inside of a short window of time. 


Because this is basically the same idea as the Painted Flower Pots craft, just with pumpkins instead of flower pots, I figured instead of doing a full tutorial, I'd take you on a little trip down memory lane. 


Circa 2000 


Pumpkin my dad decorated.
Pumpkin my dad decorated.

As a kid, we painted pumpkins instead of carving them because painted pumpkins last much longer. One year, we were at my cousins' house for a Halloween party. Each kid was given a pumpkin and a marker, and we were told we could draw our designs on the pumpkin, and then my uncle would carve them. Dad warned us not to carve them because they would spoil quickly. I was determined to listen to Dad, but pretty soon I was the only one without a carved pumpkin, and that was when I caved. Fast forward a week, and my pumpkin was already rotting. That was when I swore off pumpkin carving. 


2020


Wayton Manor pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2020.
Wayton Manor pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2020.

I was participating in a virtual Halloween challenge, and one week we had to decorate pumpkins. I think it might have been a pumpkin carving challenge, but it was super laid back, so I decided I would paint a pumpkin instead, just like I used to do when I was a kid. Wayton is a mashup of Brian's and my last names, and the little bats are supposed to represent us.


2021


Haunted cemetery pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2021.
Haunted cemetery pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2021.

I had so much fun decorating my pumpkin in 2020, I decided to make pumpkin painting an annual tradition. I decided to go with a cemetery scene this time around and was really proud of how the moon came out.


2023


Horrorscope Volume 3 pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2023.
Horrorscope Volume 3 pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2023.

I had my first horror piece published this October. My short story "The Doll" appeared in Horrorscope Volume 3. I thought it would be fun to paint my pumpkin to match the book cover to commemorate.


2024


Me dressed as the woman with the black veil from my story "Jane" with my Grizzly: A Charity Anthology pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2024.
Me dressed as the woman with the black veil from my story "Jane" with my Grizzly: A Charity Anthology pumpkin I painted for Halloween 2024.

After my success with my Horrorscope pumpkin, I decided to make bookish pumpkins the norm. My short story "Jane" had recently appeared in Grizzly: A Charity Anthology, so I made a Grizzly pumpkin. I also dressed up as the woman with the black veil from my story. 


2025


Me dressed as Alice Drayton from Little White Flowers with my Little White Flowers pumpkin painted for Halloween 2025.
Me dressed as Alice Drayton from Little White Flowers with my Little White Flowers pumpkin painted for Halloween 2025.

This was the year my debut novel came out, so of course, I had to paint a pumpkin for Little White Flowers. The cover of Little White Flowers is very detailed, far beyond what I could reproduce on a pumpkin, so I had to go for a symbolic representation. The white rose is a core symbol in both the first book and the series as a whole. A little too happy for a horror book, so I added some blood spatter to the rose for a finishing touch. I also dressed up as protagonist Alice Drayton.


2026


Me, once again dressed as Alice Drayton, with my Hallowed Deadly Seeds pumpkin painted for Halloween 2026.
Me, once again dressed as Alice Drayton, with my Hallowed Deadly Seeds pumpkin painted for Halloween 2026.

My second novel, Hallowed Deadly Seeds, came out over the summer, so of course I had to do a pumpkin for it. Since the cover image depicts a cemetery scene, I decided to put the title on a headstone. I also used the Deadly Seeds Press logo at the top of the headstone. Fun fact about that: the logo actually comes from a foam tombstone I designed years for a Little White Flowers character. (You can learn more about that headstone in my Halloween Foam Tombstone post.) I also wanted to incorporate a rose somehow but didn't feel like painting one on. I had been experimenting with making some paper rose bookmarks and decided to tape one of those to the pumpkin. The tape ended up peeling up some of the paint on the pumpkin, so not the greatest idea. But hey, it was worth a try. Same Alice Drayton costume as last year as well.


Those are all the pumpkins I've got for you. So tell me, are you a pumpkin painter? A pumpkin carver? What's your favorite pumpkin you've decorated? I'd love to know!


Comments


​FOLLOW ME

  • Instagram
  • Threads
  • Bluesky
  • Youtube
  • images
  • Facebook Social Icon

© 2026 by Amber Hathaway. Created with Wix.com

bottom of page